In the briefing room: Smartsourcing with the Mechanical Turk
Smartsheet Smartsourcing is a new offering that provides on-demand access to virtual workers who can be employed on a task-by-task basis.
Amazon.com originally developed the Mechanical Turk for use in projects for the company’s e-commerce site. It was so well received that the company then decided to open up the service beyond its originally intended in-house use to external customers. Unfortunately, many potential users were turned off by an unfriendly user interface,
Enter Smartsheet. The company’s management recognized that the existing Smartsheet collaborative spreadsheet product could serve as an easy-to-use interface to the virtual worker cloud.
Here’s how it works. From the Smartsheet interface, users enter a detailed description of the task and indicate how much they are willing to pay for it (rates can be set anywhere between $0.01 and $5.00). They then select parameters such as a due date, number of workers, and the minimum approval rating of workers that will be accepted. The rating is a percentage that reflects any time that workers’ work was rejected by a user. Paying more and accepting only higher ranked workers should result in higher quality output. Smartsheet links the request with Amazon’s Mechanical Turk, connecting the user to the virtual workforce, which then picks up the task and completes it.
Smartsourcing seems best suited for research, transcription, image tagging, copywriting, and other discrete tasks that can be broken out and are simple and clear in nature. For example, we used Smartsourcing as a kind of brainstorming tool to solicit examples of an information overload problem. The service did work and we did get a few usable results. In hindsight, our query may not have been the best use of the system, perhaps due to the difficulty of explaining exactly what we were looking for. In Smartsourcing, the final work product is largely dependent on the clarity of the query. Tasks that can be communicated clearly, such as filling in cells on a spreadsheet, or developing lists of contacts with biographical information, are well suited for Smartsourcing.
With this new product, Smartsheet is offering organizations new ways of managing work by allowing them to outsource tasks that are time consuming and of lower value than other work. By allowing knowledge workers in an organization to focus on higher value work, Smartsourcing ultimately allows managers to deploy resources more intelligently and maximize the efficiency of knowledge worker assets.
Cody Burke is a senior analyst at Basex.

March 19th, 2009 13:45
Cody, you are correct in the range of utility we’re seeing from customers using this feature within Smartsheet. There has been a particularly high concentration of data gathering jobs submitted for things like building lists, filling out additional information in existing lists, and data cleansing (i.e. – get me the names of everyone that blogs about athletic equipment in the U.S., and/or fill out specific content about each blogger listed, then assemble data about their blog that helps characterize their audience). We’ve written a brief explanation of how to get even more out of this kind of research by utilizing a couple more of our features in the following blog post:
http://www.smartsheet.com/blog/brent-frei/smartsourcing-how-obtain-high-quality-lists-through-mechanical-turk
As with any first of a kind service (virual worker access from within a general work management tool) it’s been an bit of an evangelical sale. Customers spend a little time getting their mind around a capability that hasn’t existed anywhere before. Tell someone that they can submit a list of 1,000 company names for 5 cents a piece and get the names and contact details for any particular exec at those firms within a few hours, and they simply disbelieve its possible. Or, that they can spend a dime to get a reporter’s email address, or 25 cents to have a list of reference sites assembled on a topic (offload the busy work embedded in typical projects like a product launch). Two minutes to set up a request and 50 cents is quickly replacing ‘do it yourself’ for the busy work within our customer ranks. Here’s a nice example use along that line – http://www.womengrowbusiness.com/2009/03/entrepreneurial-shock-online-project-collaboration/
-Brent Frei
March 23rd, 2009 02:03
Smartsheet: Smartsourcing with the Mechanical Turk…
Smartsheet Smartsourcing is a new offering that provides on-demand access to virtual workers who can be employed on a task-by-task basis.
Amazon.com originally developed the Mechanical Turk for use in projects for the company’s e-commerce site. It …
March 23rd, 2009 08:48
Jon Spira just alerted me to the post – made a blog entry on my blog at http://markturrell.wordpress.com/2009/03/23/smartsourcing-ill-give-you-200-if-you-tell-me-what-it-is/
It is definitely a concept that will be more and more interesting to look at as we enter a brave new world of social-computing enabled employment. I was trying to say ‘work’, but I believe that with the current economic situation being what it is, people will try to be gainfully employed, whatever that will mean in practice.
Great topic to highlight – nice piece. Thanks, Mark